The 5-Year Rule for Home Prices: Why Short-Term Dips Don’t Tell the Whole Story

If you’ve seen recent headlines about home price dips or price corrections, you’re not alone. But let’s clear the air—short-term declines don’t erase the long-term gains we’ve seen in markets like Fort Lauderdale, Oakland Park, Weston, and Pembroke Pines.

Understanding the 5-Year Rule in Real Estate

The “5-Year Rule” is a rule of thumb in real estate that says: if you plan to own your home for five years or more, you’re likely to come out ahead—even if the market dips slightly in the short term. It’s based on historical data showing that real estate values almost always rise over longer periods of time.

In fact, home prices have appreciated an average of 4.56% year-over-year over the past few decades, even when you account for recessionary years like 2008.

Let’s Look at the Numbers

Since 2020, many areas in the U.S. have seen significant price growth:

• Austin, TX: +33.3% (even after recent dips)
• Tampa, FL: +29.4%
• New York, NY: +47.4%
• Miami, FL: +50.8%
• San Diego, CA: +57.8%
• Newark, NJ: +35.9%

While some cities are experiencing a short-term cooling or correction, those long-term gains far outweigh the momentary losses. That’s the power of owning real estate for five years or more.

What This Means for Fort Lauderdale and Broward County

Here in South Florida, values have surged since 2020. If you’re asking, “How much is my Fort Lauderdale home worth?” or thinking about buying or selling in Weston, Pembroke Pines, or Oakland Park, the short answer is: you’re in a strong equity position.

Even if home values soften slightly in 2025, chances are, if you bought your property 3–5 years ago, you’re still sitting on impressive appreciation—and that gives you options.

Is Now Still a Good Time to Buy?

Yes—if you plan to stay put for 5 years or more. Short-term investors may feel the bumps, but long-term homeowners build wealth through real estate. The key is location, timing, and working with a pro who understands the market dynamics in your area.

📞 Call Scott today at 954-342-6180
📧 Email scott@reallistingagent.com
👉 Or Schedule Your Free Consultation

Bottom Line

If you’re holding off on buying or selling because you saw a price dip on the news—take a step back. Look at the past 5 years. That’s where the real picture becomes clear.

Real estate isn’t about chasing the highs and avoiding the lows. It’s about playing the long game—and in South Florida, the long game has delivered.

💬 Ready to talk about your home’s value? Use our Free Home Valuation Tool today.

PROPERTY SEARCH